Toys for Dogs That Like to Shred [DIY and Amazon]

Keeping your dog happy is usually a top priority, but that can be hard when your pup is happiest shredding apart everything in sight. This behavior is natural, and finding a toy for dogs that like to shred is a great way to satisfy that need.

Not only will we help you find a toy for your dog that likes to shred, but we’ll also guide you through some DIY options and help you better understand why your dog loves it so much. So get ready to join a dog’s world, and learn the ways of shredding.

toys for dogs that like to shred
Toys for Dogs That Like to Shred [DIY and Amazon]

Why Dogs Shred Toys?

If your dog is regularly shredding toys or worse things, like your possessions, it might be helpful to figure out exactly why they’re releasing energy this way. Here are a few of the fundamental reasons dogs like to shred apart toys.

colorful dog toys
A happy puppy playing with his colorful dog toys outdoors.

Enrichment Shredding 

Enrichment shredding is the safest and best type of shredding your dog can do. Shredding is a natural desire or instinct for some dogs, and getting a positive, designated outlet through toys helps them burn this energy in constructive ways.

Getting toys for dogs that like to shred will help them focus on shredding the appropriate materials and can help distract them from taking this instinct out on other belongings.

Anxiety Shredding

Anxiety shredding is sometimes an unfortunate side-effect. Like humans, dogs can sometimes suffer anxiety from difficult events like separation from their humans or other outside stressors.

If the shredding seems connected to specific times or activities, providing a toy for the dog that likes to shred can help them expel that energy.

Boredom Shredding

If a dog suddenly develops a shredding issue, boredom shredding is usually one of the most common reasons. They’re not receiving enough physical or emotional enrichment and are trying to supply it themselves.

New toys or shredding activities are a source of excitement that helps alleviate this boredom.

Destructive Shredding

Destructive shredding can be the most frustrating. Your pup is usually struggling with their frustration or anxiety when they act out. It can be hard to stay understanding when there is damage.

Here’s a guide to getting dogs to stop chewing apart everything if they seem to be a destructive shredder. New toys might help distract them, but it’s also good to check out some training if it seems like a significant issue.

Bojafa Dog Puzzle Teething Toy – Best For Sneaking Health Into Shredding

These rubber balls are tough toys for dogs that like to shred. They can hold up for a long time, and their unique design helps break down plaque and massage your dog’s gums while playing.

Sale
Dog Puzzle Teething Toys Ball Nontoxic Durable Dog IQ Chew Toys for Puppy Small Large Dog Teeth Cleaning/Chewing/Playing/Treat Dispensing Dog Toys (2 Pack)
  • ☆ Valued and Best Pack of 2 dog toy balls: Green and Cyan with light mint scent. Help Clean Teeth and Prevent Plaque and Tartar Build Up.
  • ☆ These tough durable dog balls are made of Non-Toxic rubber material : more durable, healthy and puncture resistant compared with PVC and TPR.
  • ☆ Special design for dog puzzle toy balls : which can be stuffed with pet snack. Your pets will accept this toy easily and get more surprise while playing. Best Dog Toys for Boredom.
  • ☆ A smarter IQ training toys for cats puppy dogs : which can be used as dog fetch play balls for outdoor games.Keep Puppy Dogs from Chewing others.
  • ☆ Rubber Dog Teething Cleaning Toys Ideal for Cat, Puppy,Small Dogs, Medium Dogs, Even Large Dogs Aggressive Chewers (ball diameter:2.8inch).

Not only that, but these balls can have treats hidden inside for mental enrichment. It will be especially helpful for pups that are struggling with boredom.

These balls come in sizes for smaller and mid-large breed dogs, the larger size being around the size of a tennis ball. The size may be too small for very large breeds, like Great Danes.

Pros:

  • Multi-function toy that helps with teeth and mental enrichment
  • Treat dispenser
  • Long-lasting and durable rubber
  • A mid-sized ball that can fit a variety of breeds

Cons:

  • The balls are mint-scented, which some dogs may dislike.
  • It may be too small for larger breeds like Great Danes.
American Pit Bull Terrier playing
American Pit Bull Terrier playing with a ball.

BarkBox 2-in-1 Interactive Plush Puzzle Dog Toys – Best For Shredders With a Surprise Inside

BarkBox’s 2-in-1 toy has an outer layer for your dog to destroy to reveal an inner, resilient toy. Let your dog enjoy his natural drive a little with these fun toys for dogs that like to shred.

BarkBox 2-in-1 Interactive Plush Puzzle Dog Toys - Squeaky Pet and Puppy Enrichment Toys for Small, Medium, and Large Dogs | Consuela The Cactus
  • Meet Consuela the Cactus: This plush cactus is densely packed with fluffy stuffing and interactive elements that are perfect for shredding, trashing, and squeaking!
  • Longer-lasting: This toy is designed to be destroyed, with a smaller squeaker inside to surprise your pup and make for long lasting playtimes. Non-toxic plush from only the most high-quality manufacturers ensures that this toy is safe for all pups to play with.
  • Active Lifestyle Ready: Great for playing, fetching, or tug of war. Fun addition to your dog's active lifestyle. Outlast and outperform other dog toys! Thoroughly-tested. Keep your pup entertained and safe during playtime with a high quality, detailed designed dog toy. Great for medium/large dogs. Perfect for bonding and relationship building.
  • Two Toys in One: Great value of the 2-in-1 toy is fun for your pup and a great bonding experience for you both!
  • Playtime Has Never Been More Fun: Consuela’s whip-n-flip arms are perfect for thrashing or tugging. Your dog is sure to have a ball and stay engaged with the added benefit of playful stress relief.

These toys come in various cute designs and sizes for small, medium, and large dogs. They’re some of the only plush toys safe for dogs to shred with supervision. Once your dog has gotten through the fabric layers, they’ll find a squeaky rubber ball to keep playing.

Despite its reputation for being made for chewers, it might still go pretty quickly, depending on your dog. Plus, you’ll want to keep an eye on your dog when they have this toy. It’s not one to leave your puppy with while you’re out.

Pros:

  • Multiple toys could mean days’ worth of play
  • Excitement and enrichment for your dog revealing each toy
  • Various designs and sizes
  • Durable inner squeaky ball

Cons:

  • The outer layers of fabric could be less durable than advertised, depending on your dog
  • The toy could be unsafe for dogs to play with alone
dog with toy
A dog busy playing with his toy.

KONG Jumbler Ball – Best For Longevity Against Shredders

The classic KONG brand is known for its tough toys, and this jumbler ball is no exception. This fun toy features an inner tennis ball meant to grab your dog’s attention, and its design is easy to toss around for fetch or to enjoy tug of war.

KONG Jumbler Ball L/XL -ASSORTED
  • Squeaker and tumbling interior ball entice play
  • Ideal for interactive fun
  • Handles make pick up and shaking easy
  • Available in two shapes: Ball and Football

This toy for dogs that like to shred should hold up to their aggressive chewing. The durable plastic can be a little stiff. The inner ball also squeaks, enticing your pup to play.

Although these toys should be hard to destroy, they have a weak spot at the seal where the company originally put the inner tennis ball. Your dog can exploit this if they’re known to be adept at finding soft spots.

Pros:

  • Classic KONG brand has trusted quality
  • Inner squeaky toy
  • Great for fetch and tug of war
  • Durable design

Cons:

  • A weak spot does exist at the seal
Labrador puppies play kong toys
Two Labrador puppies playing Kong toys.

DIY Options

DIY options are a great way to get involved in your dog’s play and give them materials they’ve never encountered before. If you’re looking for more DIY ideas related to other topics, the ASPCA has a handy list of resources.

Here, we’ll break down some great DIY specifically meant for dogs that like to shred.

labradoodle vs wall
Labradoodle Max looks at a toilet paper wall obstacle

Cardboard Destruction Boxes – Best For Reusing Items Around the House

A cardboard destruction box is what it sounds like, although it doesn’t have to be limited to cardboard. You can also use egg cartons, toilet paper tubes, or other tearable paper products.

One example could be stuffing a paper towel roll with a crumpled piece of paper, with hidden small treats mixed in, intriguing your dog. If this is the first time, it might also help if you rip the cardboard yourself, so the dog gets the idea to start their search and know it’s okay.

You’ll want to watch so that the dog doesn’t eat the cardboard. Making these toys can be a great way to reuse some cereal boxes and other cardboard.

Pros:

  • Reuse materials you probably already have
  • Get involved with your dog’s play
  • Enjoy watching your dog figure it out
  • Mental enrichment with hidden treats

Cons:

  • Has to be supervised
  • This could lead to dogs associating these items with toys

Veggies and Bones – Best For Safe to Eat Shredding

If your dog loves to eat what they shred, much to your dismay, you can find a safe way for them to enjoy this activity. Some dogs will be more receptive to this than others, depending on how picky an eater they are. 

You can use dog-safe veggies like lettuce, celery heads, carrots, spinach, or cucumbers. These are enriching to dogs since they don’t usually receive them. Make sure you keep these in smaller amounts. They’ll enjoy the fun of shredding something apart they can eat. 

You can also try bones for dogs that like to shred. If you’re looking for something more durable, natural examples like deer antlers or hooves are sturdy options for chewers. 

Pros:

  • Enriching to try new foods and treats
  • Provides some variety for their diet
  • Peace of mind that they can shred and eat their activity

Cons:

  • These should only be treats, so they shouldn’t be given too often
  • Seasoned, herbed or spiced foods are not safe for dogs

Stuffing Shreddables – Best For Adding Fun to Old Toys

A great DIY way to add fun to your old toys for dogs that like to shred is by stuffing them with shreddable paper. Any solid rubber toy with holes can be for this, but hollow balls can make the best option.

Essentially, take easy to shred paper, like printer paper or wrapping paper, and stuff it into old toys. Doing this can bring new excitement back to toys your dog has long abandoned.

If your dog wants more of a challenge, you can also use old t-shirts or other fabric options that will be harder to rip out of the toy. Feel free to mix in treats to add some fun food motivation.

Pros:

  • Revive interest in old toys with low-effort and low-cost
  • Reuse old wrapping paper
  • Can include treats
  • Easy to create

Cons:

  • Requires that your dog already has a hollow, hard rubber toy

Other Important Factors to Consider

Dogs that shred should usually have supervision while they play, and as an owner, it’s key to pay extra attention to the toys they get. There are a variety of materials that are unsafe for dogs to eat if they shred them to pieces.

Here are a few essentials to keep in mind when looking for toys for dogs that like to shred.

labradoodle in party hat
My Labradoodle Max wearing his party hat. Stylish!

My Labradoodle Max should in theory be safe with most toys – but in reality, his teeth will shred EVERYTHING and we need to be incredibly mindful. One of my biggest fears for Max as a dog owner is that he will eat stuffing from a dog bed or stuffed you.

Avoid things like:

  • Standard plushies that aren’t for heavy chewers
  • Toys with stuffing
  • Felt or fabric toys that rip easily
  • Rope or string toys that rip apart into tiny fibers

Choose toys instead that are:

  • Solid rubber or other durable materials
  • Made for larger breeds or heavy chewers

If your dog is causing an issue with their destructive chewing, you can also find help with the ASPCA list of actions to dissuade this behavior.

Bernese Mountain dog plays with owner
Bernese Mountain dog playing a rubber ball with his owner.

Final Thoughts

Getting a toy for a dog that likes to shred can sometimes seem like a handful, but nothing is more worth it than seeing those happy, wagging tails. These options are safe ways to explore that instinct with your pup, so enjoy your shredding!